18 Best Baptism Gifts to Celebrate Their Blessing

Every editorial product is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links. Ratings and prices are accurate and items are in stock as of time of publication.

Find sweet baptism gifts for girls and boys, plus gender-neutral ideas too!

First communion baptism composition with christianity symbols and white tulipsudra/Getty Images

A baptism is certainly a milestone to celebrate. And with that celebration comes the need for a special gift. If you’re a grandparent or godparent looking for the perfect baptism gift idea, something unique, personalized or handmade is sure to bring a smile. From Noah’s Ark toy sets to cross pendants and personalized date prints, these baptism gifts for boys, girls and gender-neutral options will serve as a sweet, sentimental way to commemorate the occasion.

Planning a celebration? Be sure to consider these tasty baptism party recipes.

Best Baptism Gifts for Boys

Baptism Gift Boy, Personalized PRINTABLE, Baby Boy Gift, Baptism Sign, Nursery Wall Art, Dedication Gift, Godson, Nursery Decor, PRINTABLEVia HealingWordsStudio/Etsy.com

Personalized Baptism Date Print

Commemorate the special day with a personalized print. Choose your size, add the child’s name and the baptism date. Once it’s received, frame the print to serve as the perfect piece of wall art for years to come.

Shop Now

Noahs Ark Wooden Toy SetVia potterybarnkids.com

Noah’s Ark Toy Set

This toy set is not only adorable, but it also fits the baptism theme. Made from solid birch wood, it’s long-lasting so it can be played with, bringing the story of Noah’s Ark to life, for many years. How cute are the matching sets of zebras?

Shop Now

Sailboat Box - Baptism Gift, Baby Gift or First Communion Gift - Personalized GiftVia Susabellas/Etsy.com

Personalized Sailboat Box

This simple clay sailboat box is as sweet as can be. Select a cross, an anchor or another graphic to go under their name, along with other personalized details. As they grow, they can use the box as a place to stash their favorite treasures.

Shop Now

'Special Occasion' Crib ShoeVia nordstrom.com

Boys Crib Shoes

Make sure the man of the hour is dressed to impress for the baptism. These little booties are so charming as a pre-baptism gift and can be worn again and again.

Shop Now

Baby Boys White Pique Vest Cotton Romper Baptism Outfit Set 12-18MVia walmart.com

Cotton Baptism Romper

A baptism is an occasion to dress up for, after all. This adorable cotton romper is the perfect outfit, complete with a pique vest and a matching hat to make it that much cuter.

Shop Now

Willow Tree Guardian Angel, Sculpted Hand-Painted FigureVia amazon.com

Guardian Angel Sculpture

Give the gift of a guardian angel for a baptized boy. Carved out of resin and hand painted, this Willow Tree guardian angel sculpture is the ideal trinket to set on a dresser or nightstand to watch over him.

Shop Now

Best Baptism Gifts for Girls

14k Gold Cross NecklaceVia nordstrom.com

Gold Cross Pendant

It’s never too soon for a gorgeous piece of jewelry, and this gold cross necklace for toddlers is the perfect fit. Celebrate a beautiful baptism with 14-karat gold that will turn into a family heirloom.

Shop Now

Mary Jane Crib ShoeVia nordstrom.com

Girls Baptism Shoes

Is there anything sweeter than little white baby shoes? These crib shoes are perfect for a baptism, with beautiful, embroidered detailing and an adorable, scalloped trim. Plus, the strap is adjustable for easy on and off.

Shop Now

Wooden Name Puzzle | Toddler Toys | Baby Girl Gifts | Gift for Kids | First Birthday | Birthday GiftVia ABOONstore/Etsy.com

Personalized Name Puzzle

A personalized gift can always go such a long way, and this wooden name puzzle is the ideal surprise for a little lady. Add in a name while ordering, and this handmade wooden puzzle will show up beautifully painted and ready to be played with, just in time to serve as a baptism gift.

Shop Now

Baptism Gift Girl, Personalized PRINTABLE, Baby Girl Gift, Nursery Wall Art, Godchild Baptism Sign Dedication Gift, Nursery Decor, PRINTABLEVia HealingWordsStudio/Etsy.com

Personalized Baptism Print

Celebrate a baptism with an adorable piece of wall art for her nursery. This baptism name print comes in a variety of sizes, with the option to add in the child’s name and the baptism date to make it a truly one-of-a-kind baptism gift.

Shop Now

Baby Girl Christening Gift / Baptism Gift GirlVia PetelkaUA/etsy.com

Baptism Rattle

If you look closely on this beautiful rattle, you can see an engraved cross on one of the wooden rattle pieces, making it a sweet baptism gift. The pastel hues are incredibly charming, and the wooden fish is a fitting design to tie it all together.

Shop Now

Sterling Silver & Cultured Pearl BraceletVia nordstrom.com

Silver Pearl Bracelet

Diamonds may be a girl’s best friend, but pearls are truly timeless. She’ll grow into this sterling silver bracelet, which will shine on her wrist as a special memento of her baptism.

Shop Now

Best Gender Neutral Baptism Gifts

Blessed Baby Onesie® | Infant Bodysuit | Baby BoutiqueVia LilyandGraceKids/Etsy.com

Blessed Onesie

Commemorate the special occasion with a new, special outfit. This gender neutral onesie is great for a little boy or little girl who has just been baptized and is ready to make their debut. Here are even more fantastic gift ideas.

Shop Now

2-Piece Baptism Covered Box with Rosary SetVia bedbathandbeyond.com

Rosary Box Set

This sentimental set is sure to please. Made out of ceramic, this little lamb box holds a white rosary that will serve as a keepsake throughout a little one’s childhood.

Shop Now

Personalized Piggy Bank, Gender Neutral Decor, Rainbow Decor, Coin Bank, Kids Birthday GiftVia BloomOwl/Etsy.com

Personalized Piggy Bank

It’s never too early to start a piggy bank, and the little one in your life will have so much fun with this baptism gift. Personalize this handmade, wooden bank with a name and select the perfect color palette to create a truly treasured gift.

Shop Now

ebba Blessing Lamb - 12" Wind Up MusicalVia walmart.com

Blessing Lamb

Bless the child with a lovely lamb. But this isn’t just any other stuffed animal. This sweet lamb will keep your little one cozy by singing a hymn as they fall asleep.

Shop Now

Baptism Gift Girl Baptism Gift Boy - 10x20 Matted Print *Frame Option* - Personalized Baptism Gifts from The Christian Alphabet™Via TheChristianAlphabet/Etsy.com

Alphabet Canvas

The intricacy of this personalized alphabet canvas is truly incredible, especially as it brings Christian artwork into the mix. Choose the mat color, frame and specifics such as hair color for a truly personalized name print that’s a perfect baptism gift for boys or girls.

Shop Now

My First Bible Stories Padded Treasury Book - Gifts for Easter, Christmas, Communions, Birthdays, Ages 4-8Via amazon.com

Baby’s First Bible

Of course, a Bible is a classic baptism gift idea. But this hardcover children’s book of Bible stories takes the idea to a new level of special. With super colorful illustrations, plus padding to keep the book kid appropriate, this is the ideal introduction to bible stories.

Shop Now

Popular Videos

Molly Allen
Molly Allen is a previous bakery owner and former event planner. Now, a freelance writer and editor focused on food and beverage, lifestyle, travel and parties, she brings her years of experience and industry knowledge to readers across a variety of platforms.