Instant Oats vs. Old-Fashioned Oats: Which Is Best for Baking?

If you've ever been part of the old-fashioned oats vs. quick oats debate when it comes to baking, let this set the record straight on what's what.

It’s baking time! You’re set to whip up monster cookies or oatmeal dinner rolls—and discover that the recipe calls for quick-cooking oats. But there are only old-fashioned oats in the cupboard. Can you cross your fingers, swap it out and hope for the best?

Here’s everything you need to know about substituting old-fashioned and quick-cooking oats (and one of our favorite hacks for making your own quick-cooking oats at home).

What Are Old-Fashioned Oats?

All oats start out the same: as oat groats. The difference lies in how much they’ve been processed: old-fashioned oats have been steamed and flattened. They hold their shape and texture well, making them popular choices for cookies and baked goods. They’re also great for overnight oats—because of the way they’re processed, they’re safe to eat “raw.” And yes, this is your excuse to try out some of our favorite oatmeal cookie recipes.

Rolled Oats vs. Old-Fashioned Oats

Rolled oats are another term for old-fashioned oats, so if you see that in a recipe, you’re good to go! They are sometimes also called whole oats. Learn more about the different types of oats.

What Are Quick-Cooking Oats?

Quick-cooking oats are more processed than old-fashioned oats. They’re precooked, dried and flattened, which allows them to do exactly what they promise: they can be prepared a lot faster—just needing some water—so you can whip up breakfast in minutes. But because of their convenience, they tend to lose their texture, are mushier and don’t have as distinct of a flavor.

Here are some of our go-to brands for instant oatmeal.

How to Substitute One Kind of Oats for Another

The good news? Old-fashioned oats and quick-cooking oats are basically interchangeable, although they will slightly change your final dish.

If you’re substituting old-fashioned oats for quick-cooking oats, your final dish will be chewier, and it might be a little oat-ier. If you replace old-fashioned oats with quick-cooking oats, your dish will have less texture.

You can also make your own quick-cooking oats. Toss your old-fashioned oats in a food processor and pulse a few times to get them to mimic quick-cooking oats. Voila! Problem solved. Just don’t do it too long, or you’ll end up with oat flour!

You might also encounter steel-cut oats. These oats have been chopped, rather than rolled, so they’re chewier, retain their shape while cooking and take the longest to cook. You won’t want to substitute them for rolled or quick-cooking oats. But steel-cut oats are delicious in apple pie oatmeal.

Popular Videos

Kim Bussing
Kim Bussing is a writer and editor living in Los Angeles. She has written for publications including Reader’s Digest, Modern Farmer, Clean Plates and Vice, among others, and she is working on her first novel. She is always on the hunt for the perfect gluten-free cinnamon roll.