Save on Pinterest

23 Culver’s Copycat Recipes

Every region has a favorite fast food chain. In the Midwest, it's Culver's. We found spot-on copycat recipes from the beloved restaurant—including butter burgers and custard—that you can make right at home.

1 / 23
Wisconsin Butter Basted Burgers Exps Thsum18 205850 D02 02 5b Wo Beer 122

Inspired By: Butterburger “The Original”

It’s no secret that Wisconsinites love their dairy—so much that they sometimes top their burgers with a generous pat of butter. My recipe is a lot like the butter burgers you’ll find in popular restaurants all over the state. —Becky Carver, North Royalton, Ohio —Becky Carver, North Royalton, Ohio
2 / 23
Old Time Custard Ice Cream Exps Ft19 25626 C03 13 7b Rms 2

Inspired By: Vanilla Custard

I think my most memorable summertime dessert for get-togethers has always been homemade ice cream. This recipe is so rich and creamy and the perfect indulgence on a hot summer afternoon. —Martha Self, Montgomery, Texas
3 / 23
Deep Fried Cheese Bites Exps149794 Th2377560a02 29 3b Rms 5

Inspired By: Wisconsin Cheese Curds

Cheese curds or cubes dipped in flour and beer, then fried, need only a good supply of crinkly toothpicks to turn them into a vanishing act. —Katie Rose, Pewaukee, Wisconsin
4 / 23
Exps32077 Th153340b10 02 5b 5

Inspired By: North Atlantic Cod Dinner

Dine as though you're in a traditional British pub. These moist fish fillets from the oven have a fuss-free coating that's healthy but just as crunchy and golden as the deep-fried kind. Simply seasoned and baked, the crispy fries are perfect on the side. —Janice Mitchell, Aurora, Colorado
5 / 23

Inspired By: Grilled Chicken Sandwich

I created this chicken sandwich recipe based on a meal my daughter ordered at a restaurant. She likes to dip her sandwich in the extra honey-mustard sauce. —Marilyn Moberg, Papillion, Nebraska
6 / 23
Exps192832 Th163619d09 30 2b 42

Inspired By: Chicken Noodle Soup

My first Wisconsin winter was so cold, all I wanted to eat was homemade chicken noodle soup. Of all the chicken noodle soup recipes out there, this type of soup is my favorite and is in heavy rotation from November to April. It has many incredibly devoted fans.—Gina Nistico, Denver, Colorado
7 / 23

Inspired By: Georgia Peach Flavor of the Day

My state is well known for growing good peaches. This delicious recipe has been a family favorite for more than 50 years. —Marguerite Ethridge, Americus, Georgia
8 / 23

Inspired By: Beef Pot Roast Sandwich

I received this recipe when I was a newlywed, and it's been a favorite since then. The saucy steak barbecue makes a quick meal served on sliced buns or even over rice, potatoes or buttered noodles. —Lee Deneau, Lansing, Michigan
9 / 23
Exps131394  Sd143206b04 04 6b 6

Inspired By: Buffalo Chicken Tenders

These crunch-coated chicken tenders are a little sweet, a little tangy and a whole lot of fun. In half an hour, your family's new favorite dish is ready to eat. When I have extra time, I roast garlic and add it to the sauce. —Andreann Geise, Myrtle Beach, South Carolina
10 / 23

Inspired By: Banana Split

Here's a mouthwatering make-ahead dessert that looks scrumptious and tastes as good as it looks! —Elmer Thorsheim, Radcliffe, Iowa
11 / 23

Inspired By: Mashed Potatoes & Gravy

It's a cinch to jazz up instant mashed potatoes with sour cream and cream cheese, then cook and serve them from a slow cooker. For a special touch, sprinkle this creamy mashed potatoes recipe with chopped fresh chives, canned french-fried onions or fresh grated Parmesan cheese. —Donna Bardocz, Howell, Michigan
12 / 23
Toasted Reubens Exps19010 Sd143203c10 17 4bc Rms 2

Inspired By: Grilled Reuben Melt

New Yorkers say my Reubens taste like those served in the famous delis there. For a little less kick, you can leave out the horseradish. —Patricia Kile, Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania
13 / 23

Inspired By: Red Raspberry Flavor of the Day

Making homemade ice cream is fun for the whole family, and the fresh raspberry flavor of this treat makes it a perfect summer activity. Kids can shake the bags until the liquid changes to ice cream and then enjoy the reward! —Erin Hoffman, Canby, Minnesota
14 / 23
Stuffed Sweet Pepper Soup Exps10857 Gb143373c01 16 2bc Rms 1

Inspired By: Stuffed Green Pepper Soup

Tomatoes, peppers, garlic and onions are the mainstays of my garden. Being the oldest of seven children, I acquired a knack for cooking from my mom. — Joseph Kendra, Coraopolis, Pennsylvania
15 / 23
All American Bacon Cheeseburgers Exps48107 Th2379798c03 29 1b Rms 2

Inspired By: Cheddar Butterburger with Bacon

Where can you get a juicy bacon burger that is so superior to drive-thru fare? Right in you backyard with this delicious cheeseburger recipe. —Jackie Burns, Silverdale, Washington
16 / 23

Inspired By: Mint Chip Shake

Save a sleeve of Girl Scout cookies for this creamy milkshake that's fun for kids and adults, too. —Shauna Sever, San Francisco, California
17 / 23

Inspired By: Garden Fresco with Grilled Chicken Salad

If you love the flavors of the Southwest - cumin, chili powder, a little cayenne heat - this versatile recipe for grilled chicken with fresh red and green peppers gives you something more. Discover a spicy dressing that keeps well in the refrigerator, for those days when you're running late and just want a salad, or an unexpected picnic pops up. —Therese Anderson, Pine City, Minnesota
18 / 23
Breaded Fish Sandwiches Exps44923 Thhc1757658d61c Rms 4

Inspired By: North Atlantic Cod Fish Filet Sandwich

The seasoned breading of this hearty sandwich turns mild-flavored cod or halibut into a taste sensation, and the creamy sauce just keeps it going! —Mildred Caruso, Brighton, Tennessee
19 / 23
Exps12347 Mrr133247b07 30 4b Web 3

Inspired By: Cole Slaw

For me, this is the best coleslaw recipe because a package of shredded cabbage and carrots really cuts down on prep time. This creamy coleslaw recipe is great for potlucks or to serve to your family on a busy weeknight. —Renee Endress, Galva, Illinois
20 / 23

Inspired By: Fudge Pecan Sundae

For big chocolate taste, I treat my family to this thick ice cream topping. It's a snap to make the fudgy sauce, and we like it better than the store-bought kind. —Sue Gronholz, Beaver Dam, Wisconsin
21 / 23
Everything Bagel Chicken Strips Exps Sdam18 183419 B12 01 1b 7

Inspired By: Original Chicken Tenders

I love the flavor profile of everything bagels, so I re-created it with traditional breaded chicken fingers. Serve them with your favorite chicken finger dip. —Cynthia Gerken, Naples, Florida
22 / 23
Potato Chowder Exps Hscbz 15397 D08 02 1b 13

Inspired By: Potato with Bacon Soup

One of the ladies in our church quilting group brought this savory potato soup to a meeting, and everyone loved how the cream cheese and bacon made it so rich. It's easy to assemble in the morning so it can simmer on its own all day. —Anna Mayer, Fort Branch, Indiana
23 / 23
Thick Strawberry Shakes Exps Ghtjm17 38487 C01 31 4b 5

Inspired By: Strawberry Shake

Cool off with a thick and rich treat that will remind you of a malt shoppe! Nothing can beat this strawberry shake recipe. —Kathryn Conrad, Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Katie Bandurski
Katie is an Associate Editor for Taste of Home, specializing in writing and email newsletters. When she’s out of the office, you’ll find her exploring Wisconsin, trying out new vegetarian recipes and combing through antique shops.

Newsletter Unit

CMU Unit

cover
Subscribe & SAVE Save Up To 80%!