Save on Pinterest

Holiday Butters

Sweeten up dinner rolls, slather on toast, or dress up muffins with these easy and flavorful holiday butters.

1 / 13

Mocha Cashew Butter

Flavored with coffee, chocolate and cashews, this easy-to-make spread is a yummy alternative to ordinary peanut butter. Make a jar for yourself and a few more for gifts. —Mary Houchin, Lebanon, Illinois
2 / 13

Herb Butter Cut-Outs

Add this flavorful herb butter to your holiday spread for an adorable festive look. It's easy to make using your favorite holiday cookie cutters, and its unique shape is sure to spark conversation. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen
3 / 13
Pumpkin Butter Exps Pcbbz19 86531 E04 11 8b 5

Pumpkin Butter

Biting into this spiced butter on a hot biscuit or toast is absolutely heavenly. With a dash of whipped cream, you might think you were eating pumpkin pie! —June Barrus, Springville, Utah
4 / 13
Walnut Cranberry Butter Exps33877 Sd2401789d 08 13  5bc Rms 2

Walnut Cranberry Butter

"This cranberry butter is wonderful on warm bread or biscuits," recommends Corky Huffsmith of Indio, California. "Be sure to use real butter and margarine—the low-fat products have a higher water content that doesn't give the same results."
5 / 13

Stovetop Apple Butter

The taste of homemade apple butter is worth the time it takes to make this delectable spread. —Rev. Willis Piepenbrink, Oshkosh, Wisconsin
6 / 13
Honey Almond Butter Exps31178 Thcs13c02 06 5bc Rms 2

Honey Almond Butter

To me, nothing tastes better than a warm homemade muffin right from the oven and topped with this yummy flavored butter. It's also wonderful on toast, quick breads and biscuits. —Pat Hockett, Ocala, Florida
7 / 13
Exps34283 Cw1444963d32 2

Pear-adise Butter

Vanilla and rosemary accent this thick, smooth butter that positively shouts “pears” throughout. Spread some on ordinary bread and you'll have a fruity feast. —Kristina Pontier, Hillsboro, Oregon
8 / 13

Raspberry Butter

This butter will really perk up the a brunch buffet that includes homemade breads. —Helen Lamb, Seymour, Missouri
9 / 13
Exps40755 Hca1383857d84 Rms

Cinnamon Espresso Butter

I've used this tasty butter on everything from bagels to biscotti. I like to use a teaspoon of espresso powder for the instant coffee granules. —Diane Hixon, Niceville, Florida
10 / 13
Cranberry Honey Butter Exps Hmgrds18 161504 B06 08 4b 4

Cranberry Honey Butter

If you are traveling to a friend's or loved one's for the holidays, bring them something even better than a bottle of wine—this easy to whip up treat! —Arisa Cupp, Sherwood, Oregon
11 / 13

Garlic Basil Butter

Instead of serving plain butter alongside an assortment of fresh breads, prepare this herb-laden whipped butter. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen
12 / 13
Plum Apple Butter

Plum Apple Butter

This creamy, fruity butter is perfect for breads and crackers. —Nancy Michel, Lakeland, Florida
13 / 13
Cinnamon Orange Honey Butter Exps Thd18 34021 C08 01 7b 2

Cinnamon-Orange Honey Butter

This is such a delicious butter spread for afternoon tea or with a dessert bread. Just mix it up and get ready for the compliments. —Mary Bates, Cleveland, Ohio

Newsletter Unit

CMU Unit

Subscribe & SAVE Save Up To 80%!