The 30 Best Midwestern Recipes Ever, Ranked
From wild rice hot dish to Cincinnati chili, we're naming the most midwestern foods ever. Did your favorite make the cut?
1 / 30Taste of Home
The casserole might as well be the official dish of the Midwestern states. Always comforting, easy to throw together on a weeknight and-more often than not-loaded with a generous portion of cheese, casseroles-like this broccoli chicken cheesy version-are a Heartland favorite for good reason.
3 / 30Taste of Home
In Indiana and Iowa, dinner plate-sized pork tenderloins are breaded, fried, and served up on a soft hamburger bun. Start with our recipe, then turn it into a sandwich to make it Midwestern-authentic.
4 / 30Taste of Home
At the Wisconsin State Fair, you’ll find an entire pavilion dedicated to pumping out these airy dairy treats. There’s no dainty way to eat them, so just dig in and embrace the whipped creamy goodness.
6 / 30Taste of Home
If you find yourself at a county fair or festival in Indiana, chances are you’ll see lots of happy customers chowing down on these cornbread-wrapped hot dogs on a stick. And that extra squiggle of mustard? It’s a must.
7 / 30Taste of Home
Lake Superior makes for the perfect environment to grow wild rice, which Minnesotans add to soups, stews, stuffing and-of course-casseroles (or “hot dish” as locals would say).
9 / 30Taste of Home
These savory little pockets filled with meat, carrots, potatoes and onions were a lunchtime staple for copper miners in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. Now they’re the ultimate comfort food for Yoopers everywhere.
10 / 30Taste of Home
Cornfields abound all over the Midwest, and the best way to put those cobs to good use is to slather them in butter, add a little fresh basil, and grill ’em up-always in the husk-on a sunny summer day.
12 / 30Taste of Home
If you haven’t tried this smoother, thicker version of traditional ice cream, head to Milwaukee, Wisconsin, the “unofficial frozen custard capital of the world.” Or just whip it up at home, too, for an unbelievably creamy, frosty treat on a hot day.
13 / 30Taste of Home
Scandinavians flocked to the Upper Midwest in the early 19th century, bringing with them these creamy, saucy meatballs loved as an appetizer or as a meal with noodles. And-uff da!-are we ever happy they did.
15 / 30Taste of Home
Midwestern cities like Chicago, Minneapolis, Cleveland and Detroit can thank their large Polish populations for introducing these little dumplings stuffed with potatoes, sauerkraut, cheese or meat. Make this recipe at home to pump yourself up before heading to Whiting, Indiana’s Pierogi Fest every July.
16 / 30Taste of Home
This sticky sheet cake made with a combination of butter, sugar and eggs over a chewy crust is a staple sweet in the city of St. Louis. Believed to be the result of a recipe snafu by a local bakery in the 1930s, this quirky dessert is the definition of a “happy accident.” Try them in this handheld version, slightly easier to eat at parties.
17 / 30
Whether you dip ’em or eat ’em as-is, these seasoned roast beef sandwiches with giardiniera peppers are a Chicago mainstay. They may be messy, but the risk is more than worth the reward.
18 / 30Taste of Home
We’re doubling down on two Midwestern favorites here. Sauerkraut can be found all over the Heartland topping bratwurst, stuffed in pierogies, sandwiched with corned beef and stirred into hot dish (or “hotdish”), the Minnesotan version of a classic casserole.
19 / 30Taste of Home
Nebraska knows these bread-pocket sandwiches stuffed with beef, pork, cabbage, onions or sauerkraut are a true local delicacy. In fact, the Runza Restaurant chain, which originated in Lincoln, Nebraska, has a trademark on the name “runza,” and has popularized the sandwich across the Cornhusker state and beyond.
21 / 30Taste of Home
This rich, custard-style pie is so beloved in the state of Indiana, it also goes by the name of “Hoosier Pie.” With a sprinkle of cinnamon and nutmeg, it’s as simple as it is delicious.
22 / 30Taste of Home
Chocolate and cinnamon may sound like curious additions to a chili recipe, but once you pile it on spaghetti and top it “three-way,” “four-way” or beyond with cheese, onions and beans, you’ll see why it’s become an addictive favorite well past its namesake city’s borders.
24 / 30
Head to “The Hill” neighborhood of St. Louis, Missouri, and you can bet you’ll find these breaded, deep-fried ravioli appetizers on most restaurant menus. Dip ’em in marinara and thank us later.
25 / 30
Where the country’s best barbecue can be found is up for debate, but the slow-smoked style covered in a thick tomato-molasses sauce popular in Kansas City is definitely up there. Want something doubly local to the region? Make barbecued burnt ends from smoked brisket, and douse it with that spicy-sweet sauce.
27 / 30Taste of Home
Whatever you do, don’t assume these sloppy hot dogs are a product of New York. They’re true-blue Michigan through and through, and Detroiters especially are passionate about their coney dogs-topped with a ground beef chili sauce, a stripe or two of yellow mustard and chopped onions.
28 / 30Taste of Home
Chicago-style pizza is a spectacle in itself: a super-thick, buttery crust pressed up the sides of a deep pizza pan, loaded with heaps of mozzarella, traditional toppings and a layer of chunky tomato sauce on top. Though New Yorkers may scoff at the knife-and-fork variety of pie, there’s just no way you’re picking up a slice of this pizza with your hands.
29 / 30Taste of Home
These simple rolled candies can be found at potlucks, tailgate parties and holiday get-togethers all across the state of Ohio. To make them authentically, leave a small portion of the peanut butter ball open when you dip it in smooth chocolate, making them resemble their namesake nut, and state tree of Ohio.
30 / 30
Oh, Wisconsin. We love you for your indulgent snacks free of inhibition-and especially for your proclivity for deep frying just about anything. These little curds of young cheddar cheese are the perfect shape for battering, frying, piling on a plate next to a juicy burger, or enjoying them all on their own with marinara or ranch dipping sauce. If there’s anything more Midwestern than bite-sized balls of deep-fried cheese, we’re not aware of it.
Originally Published: July 15, 2020