Colby Cheese Recipes

Colby is one of our top cheeses for cooking. Take a look at all of our most satisfying recipes with colby cheese or colby jack cheese today!

Add Filter

Tater Tot Casseroles

Ground beef, sausage and cheese make this tater tot casserole with green beans a crowd-pleaser. Cayenne pepper and hot Italian sausage give it a pleasant kick. —Ryan Jones, Chillicothe, Illinois

Stovetop Cheeseburger Pasta

Cheeseburgers are delicious in any form, but I'm partial to this creamy pasta dish that seriously tastes just like the...


Taste of Home Logo

Eight-Layer Casserole

My sister shared this original recipe, but I adapted it for my family's taste. I like that it's a nutritious...


Fiesta Beef & Cheese Skillet Cobbler

I tweaked my beefy skillet cobbler until it achieved the wow factor. I must have gotten it right, as it's...


Tamale Pie

The amount of spice in this recipe is just right for my family—we prefer things on the mild side. Make...

Italian Noodle Casserole

Canned goods make it a snap to assemble this hearty Italian dish from Joann Hosbach, Las Cruces, New Mexico.


Deep-Dish Beef ‘n’ Bean Taco Pizza

My whole family enjoys this dish that tastes like a taco and looks like a deep-dish pizza. The thick tasty...

Tortilla Beef Casserole

When I first started making this casserole, I wrapped up the tortillas like enchiladas, but this way is much easier...


Burrito Pie

Layers of cheese, meat sauce and tortillas create a satisfying Mexican lasagna kids of all ages will love. The recipe...


Two-Tater Shepherd’s Pie

I love shepherd's pie, but our oldest son, Andrew, doesn't like some of the ingredients. So I adjusted my recipe...


Bacon-Colby Lasagna

With both bacon and ground beef, this hearty dish is a real crowd-pleaser. The recipe came from my grandmother, now...